Tuesday, June 02, 2009

Religious White Christians Can't Be Terrorists

On Sunday May 30, 2009, in Wichita, Kansas, Dr George Tiller, a specialist in late-term abortion procedures, was murdered in the foyer of his church during a service.

On Monday, June 1, 2009, in Little Rock, Arkansas, Private William Long was murdered and Private Quinton Ezeagwula was wounded outside a military recruiting station.

Dr. Tiller’s ‘suspected’ murderer, 51-year old Scott Roeder, faces “possible first-degree murder charges, according to the Kansas City sheriff’s department.”

Private William Long’s ‘suspected’ murderer is 23-year old Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad (formerly known as Carlos Leon Bledsoe). Muhammad was apparently being investigated by the FBI's Joint Terrorist Task Force since his return from Yemen (after his religious conversion).

Muhammad was “not part of a larger group or part of a conspiracy” (according to Lt. Col. Thomas F. Artis of the Oklahoma City Recruiting Battalion) but was nonetheless driven by "political and religious motives" (according to the Little Rock police) and will be charged with capital murder and 16 counts of committing a terroristic act.

So Scott Roeder is facing one count of murder (and two counts of aggravated assault) whilst Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad/Carlos Bledsoe is being charged with murder and sixteen counts of terrorism?

In 1996, when Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad was 11 year-old Carlos Leon Bledsoe, Scott Roeder was a 38 year-old member of the anti-government Freemen group and was charged in Topeka for having bomb components in his car (for which he served 16 months in jail and 8 months on probation before the conviction was overturned on appeal due to issues with the search of his car).

Roeder was known to Morris Wilson, a commander of the Kansas Unorganized Citizens Militia in the mid-1990s, who said "I'd say he's a good ol' boy, except he was just so fanatic about abortion. He was always talking about how awful abortion was.

According to CNN, Roeder’s associates describe him as a regular participant in anti-abortion demonstrations in Kansas City and Wichita---a characterization corroborated by one worker at the Kansas City Central Family Medicine clinic, who said that Roeder was “hard to miss” because of his height. Roeder had been interrupted several times trying to disable the locks of the clinic with epoxy, but was never convicted. Another employee of the clinic memorized Roeder’s license plate number.

Roeder has spent at least the last 8 years physically interfering with Dr Tiller’s legal and medically necessary practice with the explicit or tacit support of a network of “pro-life” religious organizations that have been pandered-to and encouraged-by the GOP, the Catholic Church and influential media personalities who have been calling abortion providers “mass-murderers” for the past 30 years or more.

And then, convinced of his ‘moral’ duties Roeder succeeded in killing Dr Tiller where others before him had failed.

Over the past 8 years Carlos Bledsoe, along with a growing number of Americans that has become a majority in the past two years, apparently became aware of the constant killing, mass arbitrary incarceration and torture of non-Christian human beings---babies, children, women and men---by a US military under orders from a wholly Republican and Christian government; and presumably convinced of his own ‘moral duty’ decided to side with the Muslim faith and then ‘protest’ by murdering a new Army recruit as blameless as anyone for the actions of the organization he’d just joined.

Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad/Carlos Bledsoe apparently acted on his own volition and without any 30 year-long explicit or implicit support from issue-specific organizations propped-up by a major political party, or exhorted to action by any media personalities with long standing social and business relationships with the same.

Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad appears to have been driven to an act of murder solely by the brief evolution of private personal convictions.

Scott Roeder, on the other hand, joined an anti government militia and then later the powerfully-represented and politically well-connected anti-abortion movement as a mature adult and acted in accordance with behaviors encouraged and praised by a long established national network of well-funded anti-abortion organizations whose members have consistently resorted to violence and murder in opposition to perfectly legal and majority public supported medical policy.

No one with national media access has appeared to defend or explain Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad’s actions, whilst Scott Roeder on the other hand is being offered affirmation of the morality of his actions by the likes of Reverend Rusty Thomas of Operation Save America and Randall Terry whose Operation Rescue organization moved from California, where it began, to Wichita Kansas specifically to terrorize Dr Tiller into closing his clinic.

Bill O’ Reilly insists that his ‘reporting’ on Dr Miller over the past four or five years has been entirely fact-based---despite the fact that O’Reilly has for example presented as ‘fact’ at least twice on his show that Dr Miller would perform abortions “any time, for no reason, for five thousand dollars”, which is simply a lie.

So one 23 year old with no evident history of political activity, incitement to violence, proof of violent intent nor any trace of material support for violence is now about to be charged with terrorism as well as murder.

At the same time one 51 year old, known to have been a member of an anti-government militia, known to have manufactured bombs and known to be a regular member of the politically supported anti–abortion movement that has a decades-long record of death threats, of bombings and of murder, faces NO terrorism charges.

“George Tiller was a mass-murderer. We grieve for him that he did not have time to properly prepare his soul to face God. I am more concerned that the Obama Administration will use Tiller’s killing to intimidate pro-lifers into surrendering our most effective rhetoric and actions. Abortion is still murder. And we still must call abortion by its proper name; murder. Those men and women who slaughter the unborn are murderers according to the Law of God Randall Terry of Operation Rescue, June 1 2009

And what's the analysis from a presumably less-extreme, more impartial and respectable religious figure?

"Yes, both Scott Roeder and Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad acted independently in their crimes this week. But while Scott Roeder’s ideology was just the fruit of his own psychological imbalance, Abdulhakim’s ideology is shared by dozens of well organized groups and thousands of men and women who have done harm to our country in the past and have sworn to wreak greater havoc on our homeland and military in the future.

Proof of this important distinction between the nature of these two tragic events has been the unanimous condemnation of Scott Roeder’s crime by every major pro-life group in our nation. That’s on the one hand. On the other hand, we get nothing but silence from the leaders of the particular strain of Islam that Abdulhakim Mujahid Muhammad studied in Yemen.

In other words, it is crystal clear that Scott Roeder, the man suspected of killing Dr. George Tiller, in no way represents the pro-life cause he heralded, while Abdulhakim will be considered a hero by many of his fellow Islamists whose cause is the destruction of America and Christianity in particular."–(emphasis added)--Father Jonathan Morris, Roman Catholic priest and FOX News Religion Contributor.

The Holy and Most Reverend Father Miller of the tax-exempt, child-molesting Catholic Church and ‘Christian’ foot-soldier of a nationwide multimedia propaganda arm of politically active religious Conservatives is doing exactly what the anti-abortion religious right has been doing for decades—ignoring the cumulative results of their own rhetorical persuasions on those who take the message to ‘serve God’ and punish the wicked according to God’s Will to heart and thus murder in God’s name according to the message of God’s ordained representatives and self appointed champions.

Apparently despite three decades of consistent death-threats, intimidation, arson, attempted bombings, successful bombings, attempted murder and assassinations directed at a select group of people for the specifically political cause of denying a majority of Americans their legal and constitutional rights in pursuit of the overthrow of a democratically determined secular law, religious white Christians Conservatives simply can’t be organized terrorists—that distinction is reserved strictly for Muslims.

7 comments:

Hackerbob said...

decided to side with the Muslim faith and then ‘protest’ by murdering

Not all Muslims protest through murder. Muslim extremists do.

Scott Roeder...acted in accordance with behaviors encouraged and praised by a long established national network of well-funded anti-abortion organizations...

Then how come all the anti-abortion groups have condemned Tillers killing. Pro-lifers do not commit murders, Extremists do.

perfectly legal and majority public supported medical policy.

1. Late term abortion on demand is illegal in Kansas.

2. 51% of Americans surveyed are against abortion.

3. 72% of Americans surveyed are against late term abortion.

So much for "perfectly legal and majority supported"

Roeder acted against a single man and assaulted two others. his was a political act against a private individual. Muhammad shot up a strip mall intending to kill more. His was a political act aimed at the (representatives)of the government.

Very well written post, 5th.

Wayne A. Schneider said...

Excellent post, 5th.

Hackerbob,

I respectfully wish to point out that I take issue with the use of the term "abortion on demand." I believe that this is a mischaracterization used by abortion opponents, to make people think that there is on onslaught of women showing up days before their babies are due just to have their pregnancies terminated on a whim. That just doesn't happen in the US, and nobody can prove that it does. O'Reilly claimed that there was evidence that Dr. Tiller was doing just that, but as is often the case with O'Reilly's lies, he couldn't point to anything that backed up his claim. But he was more than happy to claim the person who questioned this had no proof that he was wrong.

As for poll results purporting to claim that a majority of Americans are against "late term abortions," I have stated on many occasions my objections to citing polls of uninformed people. Especially when abortion is the subject. For example, in the poll result you cite, did the question ask about "late term abortions" performed to save the life of the mother? Or did the pollster leave the person answering the question with the impression that last-minute abortions for no reason are included in that?

Polls are used to manipulate people politically, not reflect what their informed views are.

But I do commend you on your respectful comments in reply.

Hackerbob said...

Wayne,

I guess you are saying that the people didn't understand the question or are you saying the question may not be specific enough? If we can not rely on polls, how can you say that a majority support abortion?

Groups have done investigations at Tillers clinic and found that he would be willing to perform abortions after viability when there were no health concerns for the mother or fetus. Here is one such case:

http://www.lifenews.com/state3754.html

Yes, it does happen in the U.S.

But to be fair to 5th and his well written post I will attempt to stay on task and re-enterate Roeder is not called a terrorist because his was a act on an individual while Muhammad's act was towards the government and it's representatives.

5th Estate said...

hacker bob

Shroeder killed Tiller because the Government permits abortions (as well as his objection to Tiller's procedures).

He could have killed Tiller any time, but took particular interest in Tiller's trial.
If Tiller had been convicted, Shoreder would have no more reason to kill Tiller.

Tiller was acquitted,his actions declared legal according to the government.
Shroeder killed Tiller because he opposed the government decision.
That would make Tiller a terrorist

5th Estate said...

hacker bob,

You write: Not all Muslims protest through murder. Muslim extremists do.

Did I even imply that “all muslims protest through murder”?
I wrote that Bledsoe decided to side with the Muslim faith and then ‘protest’ [US policies] by murdering a new Army recruit.
Murder isn’t protest of course; it’s just revenge for real (or imagined) injustice, which is why I put the word in single quotes.

I wrote: Scott Roeder...acted in accordance with behaviors encouraged and praised by a long established national network of well-funded anti-abortion organizations...
You write: “Then how come all the anti-abortion groups have condemned Tillers killing. Pro-lifers do not commit murders, Extremists do.”

Some anti-abortion groups have called Dr. Tiller’s murder justified even as they have claimed to condemn it, and those who have done-so are obviously ‘pro-lifers’.
Randall Terry of Operation Rescue, a pro life organization, said “I am more concerned that the Obama Administration will use Tiller’s killing to intimidate pro-lifers into surrendering our most effective rhetoric and actions”
The Army of God, another pro-life organization, is celebrating Dr Tiller’s murder, as it has celebrated the murders of other doctors.
Ergo “all the anti-abortion groups” have NOT condemned Tiller’s murder.
Roeder is a pro-lifer. Reverend Hill of the Army of God is a pro-lifer. Dr. Barnett Sleipian’s killer was a pro-lifer. Dr. Gunn’s killer Michael Griffin, is a pro-lifer.
The pro-life movement has produced several murderers and therefore some pro-lifers DO commit murders (and are encouraged to murder by people like Randall Terry.).

I wrote: perfectly legal and majority public supported medical policy
You wrote:
“1. Late term abortion on demand is illegal in Kansas
2. 51% of Americans surveyed are against abortion.
3. 72% of Americans surveyed are against late term abortion.
So much for "perfectly legal and majority supported"

1) “Late term abortion on demand” is a semantic construct invented by the pro-life movement to imply that abortions can be had on demand at any stage of pregnancy, as a ‘right’ that cannot be denied. That’s bullshit,
Dr. Tiller was just acquitted on 16 charges of performing illegal late term abortions. His services have been and are entirely legal (and are subject to specific restrictions and oversight by LAW).

2) and 3) Since abortion became legal in 1973 Republicans have consistently campaigned to make abortion illegal again but every time they’ve had the power to do so they have never done anything about it for the simple fact that the majority of the public supports abortion as a legal right.

For example: http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/01/21/scotus.roevwade/index.html

“Public opinion on abortion has remained remarkably stable over the years. A CNN/Opinion Research survey in October found 36 percent of Americans think abortion should be legal in most or all circumstances, 40 percent believe it should be available in a few circumstances, such as to save the mother's life, and 22 percent say abortion should never be legal. That is almost unchanged in the past 15 years.”

Therefore 76% think that abortion, per se, should be legal.

You write:
“Roeder acted against a single man and assaulted two others, his was a political act against a private individual. Muhammad shot up a strip mall intending to kill more. His was a political act aimed at the (representatives) of the government.”

Both men acted on their own convictions which were indeed political.

Muhammad did not ‘shoot up a strip mall’. Muhammad was likely encouraged to violent action by his Yemeni mentors, so in that regard he received ‘moral’ support and encouragement,

Roeder murdered alone, but he has taken encouragement from some pro-life organizations which have supported and do support his actions. Muhammad is faced with 16 counts of terrorism for one act of murder and attempted murder, whilst Shroeder faces no counts of terrorism.

not_over_it said...

Abortions on demand? Seriously? As a woman who is intelligent enough to use preventative measures when satisfying my carnal desires (screw your "abstinence only" crap!) I would, in fact, demand an abortion if my birth control failed and I became pregnant, and I would have every legal right to have one in the first trimester as long as I could pay for it.

Or I could throw myself down a flight of stairs and cross my fingers.

There are legal strings attached, all of them involving the woman's health--which was disregarded in the latest Congressional fiasco involving "late term abortions"--so, yeah. I'll demand an abortion if I want. What are you going to do, kill the "abortionist"?

There are a lot of injustices in the world, and one of them is how religious fanatics are allowed to stick their nose in my uterus!

Wait, that came out wrong..

*waves at Britisher*

How you doin'?

debipopz said...

Can you check those dates please? May has 31 days in it. If Sunday was the 30th of May, then Monday would be the 31st of May instead of the 1st of June as posted.

Thanks a bunch! I will continue to look, but this is the closest I have come to finding a date for these murders...